Identify Areas of Improvement in the Universities Ranking,ERICDATA高等教育知識庫
高等教育出版
熱門: Scopus AI  Semi-trusted loader  吳清山  Helong Xia  Qiaoyun Zhang  Zhi-Wei Sun  
高等教育出版
首頁 臺灣期刊 學校系所 學協會 民間出版 大陸/海外期刊 政府機關 學校系所 學協會 民間出版 DOI查詢服務 DOI註冊服務
篇名
Identify Areas of Improvement in the Universities Ranking
作者 Francesco Grillo
英文摘要
University rankings influence public opinions, students, faculties, funders, governments and employers. In fact, these instruments are seen as having an impact not only on the choices made by universities’ clients but also on choices and priorities of universities themselves. However, although nearly everybody agrees that rankings are "here to stay", the debate on the validity of the current mainstream rankings does not seem to be settled: it becomes even more vibrant when international league-tables are discussed with not few doubts being posed and few corrections to rankings methodologies being adopted in response to some of these critiques. Indeed, it should be considered that these instruments are still in their methodological infancy and further adaptations are expected to come in the next years. In this paper we identify five main problems of the classifications: the question of the comparability of universities; the insufficient attention to clients’ opinions; the possible negative effects of rankings on innovation; the bias toward size; the issue of the transparency of the data that are being used and of the methodology that is adopted in order to process the numbers. On the basis of these specific issues we developed some possible criteria to solve each of the above problems: indicators which can measure the success of different universities with different segment of users and with different products; assessment of impact on broader public opinions; measurement of variations in performances in order to reward progress; comparison between outputs and size of the institution so that efficiency can be appreciated; full transparency and possibility for each category of users to calculate its own ranking.
起訖頁 061-098
關鍵詞 Higher EducationInstitutions、Ranking、University Reform、Performance、Outcome、Higher EducationInstitutions、Ranking、University Reform、Performance、Outcome
刊名 高教評鑑與發展  
期數 201206 (6.1期)
出版單位 財團法人高等教育評鑑中心基金會
該期刊
上一篇
Ranking of Top Universities in Greater China

高等教育知識庫  新書優惠  教育研究月刊  Ericdata高等教育知識庫